1. What an agreement is, and what it takes to become a contract
  2. Offer and acceptance
  3. Intention to create legal relations
  4. Consideration
  5. Certainty and completeness
  6. Capacity and legality
  7. A worked example: the verbal deal that did, and did not, become a contract
  8. Common misconceptions about agreements and contracts
  9. When a commercial lawyer is worth the fee
  10. The question to ask before your next deal

Every contract in Australia starts life as an agreement, but very few agreements ever become contracts. The difference is not about paperwork. It is about whether the law will step in and enforce the promises if one side walks away.

A contract is an agreement that satisfies six legal elements. If all six are present, a court can order the party who broke the deal to pay damages or perform what they promised. If any element is missing, the other side's only leverage is goodwill. This guide sets out the six elements, shows them operating in a realistic business scenario, and deals with the common misunderstandings around verbal agreements and memorandums of understanding.

What an agreement is, and what it takes to become a contract

An agreement is any mutual understanding between two or more parties about what each will do, or not do. You agree a price with a supplier. A contractor agrees to finish a job by Friday. Two founders agree to split responsibilities. All of those are agreements, and most of them are never written down.

In Australian law, the word "contract" is reserved for agreements the law will enforce. For an agreement to cross that line, it must satisfy six elements: offer and acceptance, intention to create legal relations, consideration, certainty and completeness, capacity, and legality. Each element is examined below.

Offer and acceptance

There has to be a clear offer by one party and an unqualified acceptance by the other. An offer is a definite statement of the terms on which one party is willing to deal. Acceptance is agreement to those terms as they stand. If the other party responds with different terms, that is a counter-offer, which rejects the original offer, and the negotiation effectively starts again.

Acceptance does not have to be verbal or written. Conduct can amount to acceptance, for example starting work or paying a deposit. In most business dealings this is the least controversial element, because the exchange of quotes, purchase orders and invoices usually maps cleanly onto it.

Both parties must intend the agreement to be legally binding. Since people rarely announce that intention out loud, courts assess it objectively, by asking what a reasonable person in the parties' position would have understood from their words and conduct.

The High Court made this clear in Ermogenous v Greek Orthodox Community of SA Inc (2002) 209 CLR 95, holding that intention is not presumed for or against any particular type of relationship: it is decided from all the circumstances. In practice, commercial dealings in which money changes hands and businesses rely on promises almost always carry the necessary intention, while informal arrangements between friends or family members often do not.

Consideration

Each side must give something of value in exchange for what it receives: money, goods, services, or a promise to do something. Consideration is what distinguishes a contract from a gift. If a supplier promises to keep supplying you but receives nothing in return, that promise is not enforceable as a contract.

The value does not have to be market value, and the law does not judge whether the deal is a good one. It only requires that each side actually gives something in exchange for what it gets.

Certainty and completeness

A court can only enforce an agreement if it can work out what was agreed. Terms that are too vague, or essential terms left entirely for later agreement, mean there is nothing for the court to apply. "We will agree a price later" is not a contract term a court can enforce.

This is where informal agreements most often fail. Two people can genuinely agree on the broad shape of a deal and still have no contract, because the price, the scope of work, or the timeframe was never pinned down. A signed document does not cure this: a court will not enforce terms it cannot identify.

Capacity and legality

The parties must have the legal ability to contract. Minors, people affected by mental incapacity, and certain other situations raise capacity questions, and a court will not hold someone to a deal they lacked the capacity to make.

The purpose and terms of the contract must also be lawful. An agreement to do something illegal, such as paying an employee partly in cash to evade tax, is not a contract the courts will enforce, even if every other element is present.

A worked example: the verbal deal that did, and did not, become a contract

Nadia runs a small interior design studio. Two things happen in the same week.

First, she agrees verbally with a fitter to renovate her new studio for $48,000, with the scope set out in a quote, a start date, and payment in three instalments. She pays the first instalment and the fitter begins work. All six elements are present: offer and acceptance (the quote and her agreement to it), intention (a commercial job), consideration (money for work), certainty (price, scope and dates), capacity and legality. Nadia has a contract even though nothing was signed. If the fitter abandons the job, she can sue for breach. Her challenge will be proving the terms, not establishing that a contract exists.

Second, a larger firm signs a one-page memorandum of understanding with Nadia stating that the parties "intend to explore a possible collaboration", with no money terms and a closing line that the arrangement is "subject to a formal agreement". No contract has formed. The terms are incomplete, no consideration moves from the firm, and the "subject to a formal agreement" language shows the parties intended to be bound only later. If the firm walks away, Nadia has no legal remedy, and the document was never designed to give her one.

Common misconceptions about agreements and contracts

A few beliefs about agreements and contracts are widespread, and wrong. Here is what the law actually says:

  • Verbal agreements are never binding: They can be. A verbal deal is a contract whenever all six elements are present, and courts enforce them regularly. The real problem is proof: when memories differ and nothing is written down, it becomes hard to pin down the agreed terms. There are also statutory exceptions. In New South Wales, for example, a contract for the sale of land or any interest in land cannot be sued on unless it is evidenced in writing and signed by the party to be charged, under s 54A of the Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW).

  • Calling a document an MOU or heads of agreement makes it non-binding: The label does not decide enforceability. Courts look at the substance: the language used, the completeness of the terms, and the parties' intention. The classic authority is Masters v Cameron (1954) 91 CLR 353, applied in New South Wales in Jennings v Jennings [2015] NSWSC 1826. Where parties sign "subject to contract", they usually intend not to be bound until a formal contract is executed. But where the terms are complete and everything has been agreed, a court may find a binding contract despite the document being called an MOU. If you want a document to be non-binding, or binding only in part, say so expressly in the document itself.

  • If it is written and signed, it is definitely enforceable: A written contract is far easier to prove, but the six elements must still be satisfied. Vague terms still fail certainty, and an illegal purpose still fails legality. For companies, how the document is signed also matters. Section 127 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) sets out the standard way for a company to execute a document: signed by two directors, or by a director and a company secretary, with a special rule for a proprietary company with a sole director who is also the sole secretary or where there is no secretary. Getting execution right avoids disputes about whether the company is actually bound.

  • An agreement is a contract: It is the reverse. All contracts are agreements, but most agreements are not contracts. Only agreements that satisfy all six elements create enforceable obligations.

When a commercial lawyer is worth the fee

A lawyer's role is to tell you, before money changes hands, whether you have a contract and what it says. In practice that work looks like this:

  • Reviewing MOUs and heads of agreement: Before signing, a lawyer marks which clauses are binding now (such as confidentiality, exclusivity and governing law) and which are subject to a formal contract, so a document meant to be non-binding does not accidentally bind you.

  • Drafting the contract: A lawyer writes the terms so that price, scope, timing, liability, termination and dispute resolution are certain and complete, closing the gaps that turn a contract into an unenforceable agreement.

  • Advising on verbal deal disputes: When a deal has gone wrong and nothing was signed, a lawyer assesses whether a court will find a contract and which evidence, such as emails, invoices and conduct, will prove the terms.

  • Handling execution and formalities: This includes company execution under s 127 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), deeds, and electronic signing, so the finished document is valid and enforceable.

The benefit is straightforward. At the drafting stage, a lawyer's fee buys certainty about what each side owes. In a dispute, it buys the difference between a claim a court can enforce and a conversation about goodwill. Most businesses only discover whether they had a contract after they need one.

The question to ask before your next deal

Before you rely on any promise, run the six elements. If the other side walked away tomorrow, could you prove an offer, an acceptance, an intention to be bound, consideration moving both ways, and terms certain enough for a court to enforce? If you cannot, either write the contract or treat the arrangement as unenforceable and price in the risk.

The agreements that cost businesses the most are not the ones that failed. They are the ones the business assumed were contracts when they were only agreements. The handshake and the label on the document do not decide enforceability. The six elements do.