A contract offer is a clear expression of willingness to be bound on particular terms, made by one party to another, that becomes a contract if the other party accepts it. Every binding contract in Australian business starts with an offer, but not everything that looks like one is an offer in law. Advertisements, price lists, casual comments and counter-offers all sit on the other side of the line. This guide explains what makes an offer, the elements of the contract that surrounds it, and the rules that govern how offers are made, changed, withdrawn and accepted, so you know where you stand in your next negotiation.
What makes a statement an offer
An offer is an expression of willingness to enter into a legally binding agreement on particular terms, made with the intention that it will become binding as soon as it is accepted. The party making the offer is the offeror; the party who accepts it is the offeree. For a statement to qualify as an offer, three things generally need to be present:
- Communication: An offer only takes effect once it reaches the offeree. You cannot accept an offer you never knew about, and a business cannot be bound by terms it never saw.
- Definite terms: The offer must be specific enough to be accepted without further negotiation. If essential terms such as price, subject matter, quantity or timing are missing or vague, there is usually no offer, only the raw material for one.
- Intention to be bound: The offeror must intend, judged objectively, to be legally bound if the offer is accepted. The High Court confirmed in Ermogenous v Greek Orthodox Community of SA Inc (2002) 209 CLR 95 that intention is assessed objectively, by reference to what a reasonable person in the position of the parties would conclude from their words and conduct, not what a party privately thought.
In a business context, courts are generally willing to find that commercial statements were intended to be binding. The risk cuts the other way too. A throwaway line in a meeting or a careless email can read as a definite, intended offer even when you did not mean to commit, because the test is objective. If you want to signal that you are not yet committing, say so in the document itself, for example by marking a draft "subject to contract" or "for discussion purposes only".
Where the offer sits in a binding contract
An offer is only the first of several elements a court needs before it will enforce an agreement. In Australia, a binding contract generally requires all of the following:
- Offer: A definite proposal, as described above.
- Acceptance: The offeree agrees to the exact terms of the offer, by words, in writing, or by conduct.
- Consideration: Each party gives something of value, such as money for goods, services for payment, or a promise in exchange for a promise.
- Intention to create legal relations: Both parties objectively intend the agreement to be enforceable. As noted above, Ermogenous makes clear this is assessed from all the circumstances rather than by applying rigid presumptions.
- Certainty of terms: The terms must be clear and complete enough for a court to know what was agreed and to enforce it.
The offer is where most disputes begin, because it is the point at which the parties' words first crystallise into a legal commitment. If there is no valid offer, there is nothing for the other side to accept, and no contract.
A worked example: the quote that changed hands
Priya runs a cafe in Brisbane and emails three packaging suppliers asking what they charge for compostable coffee cups. Two of them reply with detailed quotes: 200 boxes of cups at $48 a box, delivered by 30 June, payment due 30 days after delivery. The third replies: "Thanks for your enquiry, our range starts at $45 a box and we would love to talk."
Under the rules above, only the two detailed quotes are offers. They are definite about the product, the quantity, the price and the delivery date, and a reasonable reader would take the suppliers to be willing to be bound if Priya accepted. The third reply is an invitation to treat, an invitation for Priya to make an offer of her own. It is not something she can "accept" into a contract.
Priya emails supplier one: "We accept your quote, but can you deliver by 15 June instead?" That reply is a counter-offer, and a counter-offer destroys the original offer. The supplier is no longer on the hook at $48 a box, because Priya's changed terms have replaced the offer with a new one that only the supplier can accept. When the supplier replies that 15 June is not possible, Priya's follow-up "fine, 30 June then" is itself a fresh offer. The supplier must accept it before there is a contract. A NSW Supreme Court case, CJ Bova Pty Ltd v Geoffrey Needham Pty Ltd [2009] NSWSC 1353, illustrates the same trap in commercial settlement correspondence: a response that said the party was "prepared to accept" subject to confirmation of nominated matters was held to be a counter-offer, not an acceptance, so no contract came into existence.
Priya then accepts supplier two's quote by email at 4pm on a Friday. When is the contract formed? If the parties have not agreed otherwise, an electronic communication is received, for the purposes of a law of the Commonwealth, when it becomes capable of being retrieved at the addressee's designated electronic address under s 14A of the Electronic Transactions Act 1999 (Cth). In practical terms, the acceptance takes effect when it lands in the supplier's inbox in a retrievable form, not when someone reads it. The High Court's decision in Tallerman & Co Pty Ltd v Nathan's Merchandise (Vic) Pty Ltd (1957) 98 CLR 93 applies similar reasoning to acceptances sent by post or telegram: once the acceptor has done everything required of them, the contract can be complete even before the offeror learns of the acceptance.
Common misconceptions about offers
A few beliefs about offers cause regular, expensive surprises for small businesses.
Advertisements and catalogues are offers
They are usually invitations to treat. When a shop displays stock or a business advertises a price, it is inviting customers to make offers, which the business can accept or reject. The NSW Supreme Court applied the traditional auction analysis to an online sale in Smythe v Thomas [2007] NSWSC 844, treating the listing of an aircraft on eBay as an invitation to treat and each bid as an offer the seller was free to accept or reject. There are exceptions, such as reward-style offers that invite acceptance by performance, but the default position is that advertising is not an offer. That does not leave buyers unprotected. Advertising goods at a price you cannot supply in reasonable quantities is bait advertising under s 35 of the Australian Consumer Law in sch 2 of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), and statements in advertising that mislead can breach the prohibition on misleading or deceptive conduct in s 18 of the same schedule.
Silence can be acceptance
It cannot, generally. You cannot bind someone to a contract simply because they did not reply to your offer, and you are not bound merely because you failed to respond to someone else's. If a deal depends on a reply, the offer should say so, and even then acceptance usually needs to be communicated or performed, not merely omitted.
Any response to an offer makes a contract
Only an acceptance that matches the offer exactly does. A reply that varies the terms is a counter-offer, which rejects and replaces the original offer, as the worked example above shows. By contrast, a genuine request for information, such as "what would the price be for double the quantity?", does not reject the offer; the offer stays open. Working out which category your reply falls into is a judgment call that often needs a lawyer's eye.
A verbal offer is not binding
A contract for many goods and services can be made orally or by conduct, so a verbal offer and a verbal acceptance can produce a binding contract if the other elements are present. The practical problem is proof, not validity. Written offers and acceptances are far easier to enforce because the terms are recorded.
"Subject to contract" means nothing
It can mean a great deal. The High Court held in Masters v Cameron (1954) 91 CLR 353 that where parties sign an agreement "subject to contract", they have usually made no binding contract at all, because the formal contract is intended to be the source of their obligations. The same logic applies to deals made "subject to finance" or "subject to approval". These words can also be used to make a binding contract that is merely conditional, so the precise wording matters. If you are relying on such a phrase to protect you, or think the other side's use of it has let you off the hook, get the document reviewed before you act on either assumption.
When a lawyer helps with offers
Much of the risk in this area is avoidable with advice at the right moment. A commercial lawyer can help in several ways:
- Reviewing your quotes, proposals and terms and conditions: before they go out, confirm that what you intend to be an offer is definite and clearly drafted, and that what you intend to be an invitation to treat cannot be mistaken for an offer.
- Drafting the acceptance mechanics: such as requiring acceptance in writing, setting expiry dates, and adding conditions like "subject to finance" in wording that does what you intend.
- Advising on pre-contract documents: such as heads of agreement, memoranda of understanding and letters of intent, which can be binding or non-binding depending on how they are drafted, in line with the categories recognised in Masters v Cameron.
- Assessing whether a contract was formed: including whether a reply was acceptance, a counter-offer or a request for information, and whether an offer has been validly withdrawn or has lapsed.
- Checking marketing and advertising for consumer law exposure: so that the words that invite customers do not also breach the Australian Consumer Law.
The value of that advice is that it is given before money changes hands or obligations are assumed. Disputes over whether an offer was made, accepted or withdrawn are resolved after the event by a court, at a cost that usually dwarfs the price of a review.
The question to ask before you send or accept
The mistake that costs Australian businesses the most in this area is assuming a conversation is a contract, or that a document is not one. Before you send a quote, reply to one, or walk away from a negotiation, ask yourself one question: is what is on the table an offer, an invitation to treat, or a counter-offer? An offer is definite and intended to bind, an invitation to treat is an invitation for offers, and a counter-offer has just destroyed the offer it responds to. If you cannot answer with confidence, treat the deal as not yet made and have a lawyer look at the exchange before you commit, because by the time a dispute reaches court, the words have already done their work.