1. The first element: the information must be confidential
  2. The second element: the information must have been shared in confidence
  3. The third element: unauthorised use to your detriment
  4. A worked example: the boutique spice blend
  5. Common misconceptions about breach of confidence
  6. Where a lawyer can help
  7. The question that decides your claim

Breach of confidence is a legal claim available when someone uses or discloses information you shared with them in confidence. It is an equitable cause of action, which means it was developed by the courts in case law rather than in a statute. In Australia there is no single piece of legislation that codifies the rules of confidential information. The starting point is the English decision in Coco v A.N. Clark (Engineers) Ltd [1969] RPC 41, which Australian courts have adopted and applied, including the NSW Court of Appeal in Del Casale v Artedomus (Aust) Pty Ltd [2007] NSWCA 172 and the Full Federal Court in Optus Networks Pty Ltd v Telstra Corporation Ltd [2010] FCAFC 21.

To establish a breach of confidence you need to prove three things:

  • Confidentiality: the information must have the necessary quality of confidence about it.
  • Circumstances: the information must have been imparted in circumstances importing an obligation of confidence.
  • Misuse: there must have been unauthorised use of the information to your detriment.

This article walks through each element, shows how they operate together with a worked example, and sets out the misconceptions that most often derail a claim.

The first element: the information must be confidential

The first hurdle is showing that the information was confidential in the first place. Information that is in the public domain or amounts to general common knowledge does not qualify. If a competitor could have found the information from public sources, or if it is the kind of everyday knowledge that anyone in the industry would have, a court will not protect it.

That does not mean the information must be secret in every respect. A document put together entirely from materials that are individually in the public domain can still be confidential if the particular combination, selection or arrangement is not generally known. A recipe is the classic example: the individual ingredients might be common, but the precise ratios, the order of processing and the choice of suppliers can amount to a valuable secret.

You also need to be able to identify the information with precision. Courts will not protect vague claims such as "our business strategy" or "our know-how". The claim needs to pin down what the information actually is, whether a customer list, a formula, a manufacturing process or a pricing structure.

Del Casale shows the point in practice. The respondent imported a particular stone from Italy under the name Isernia and sold it in Australia as its sole importer. The fact that Isernia was a type of modica stone sourced from the Ragusa region could not be easily ascertained, and the company deliberately gave that information only to a few people in the organisation. The court treated the information as confidential even though it might have been discoverable with enough effort.

There is also a related doctrine worth knowing. Even where confidential information later becomes public, a recipient who gained an unfair head start from it can still be restrained from exploiting that advantage. Australian courts recognise this springboard doctrine, so a leaked design can still create liability after the information has been disclosed to the world.

The second element: the information must have been shared in confidence

The second element is about the circumstances in which you shared the information. The obligation of confidence is not imposed simply because the information is secret; it is imposed because of the situation in which it was communicated. The test, drawn from Coco, is whether a reasonable person in the position of the recipient would have realised that the information was given in confidence.

A signed confidentiality agreement makes this element almost automatic to prove, but you do not need a signed document. The law protects information shared in negotiations for a joint venture, with a prospective buyer, with a contractor or with an employee, where the context makes clear that the information was not for general use. The more sensitive the information, and the more clearly it is marked or described as confidential, the easier this element is to establish.

By contrast, there is no obligation of confidence where you put the information into the public sphere yourself. If the managing director of a manufacturer gives a public presentation explaining a new production method, the people who hear it are free to use what they learned. The obligation attaches to information shared privately, not to information broadcast openly.

In business, the common cases involve information shared within commercial relationships. Joint venture partners routinely exchange commercially sensitive information such as cost structures, supplier terms and client identities. Former employees are another frequent source of claims, because employees learn a great deal about how a business operates. The difficult line, which the courts draw in cases like Del Casale, is between confidential information on the one hand and an employee's general skill, experience and know-how on the other. A former employee is generally free to use the latter, and an employer must be able to point to something more specific to succeed.

The third element: unauthorised use to your detriment

The third element is the actual harm. You must show that the recipient used or disclosed the information without your authorisation and that this caused you detriment. In Australia, detriment is treated as a genuine requirement of the claim, not a formality. In Optus Networks Pty Ltd v Telstra Corporation Ltd, the Full Federal Court applied the earlier decision in Smith Kline & French Laboratories (Aust) Ltd v Secretary, Department of Community Services and Health (1990) 22 FCR 73 on this point, and the case law treats detriment to the party who communicated the information as an essential element of the action.

Detriment is not confined to a measurable financial loss. It can include losing a competitive advantage, losing the exclusivity of a valuable asset, or losing control over information that was meant to stay private. The loss can also be prospective: a threatened or apprehended misuse can be enough to support an urgent court order stopping the recipient from using the information at all. That is often the practical point of a breach of confidence claim, stopping the leak before the market is flooded.

A worked example: the boutique spice blend

Consider a small Melbourne food manufacturer that has spent three years developing a signature spice blend sold exclusively through one national supermarket chain. The blend's recipe, its supplier list and the details of the exclusivity arrangement are kept in a locked file and shared only with the production manager under a signed confidentiality agreement.

The production manager resigns and, eight weeks later, joins a direct competitor. Within four months the competitor launches a spice blend with an identical flavour profile, using the same suppliers and undercutting the manufacturer's price. The manufacturer believes the recipe was copied.

Working through the three elements: the recipe qualifies as confidential because, while the individual spices are common knowledge, the precise combination and the supplier relationships are not in the public domain and were kept restricted. The circumstances import an obligation of confidence because the manager signed a confidentiality agreement and received the information as part of the employment relationship. The misuse is apparent from the near-identical product and the use of the same suppliers, and the detriment is the lost exclusivity and the head start the competitor gained.

The claim could fail on any of these points. If the blend's formula had been published in a trade magazine, the confidentiality element would fall away. If the manager had simply used general blending experience without copying the recipe, the case would be about legitimate know-how rather than misuse of confidential information. That is why identifying the specific information, and gathering evidence of what was actually copied, usually decides the outcome.

Common misconceptions about breach of confidence

Several misconceptions recur in practice, and each one can derail a claim if it is acted on:

  • I did not sign an NDA, so I have no claim: Not correct. The equitable obligation can arise purely from the circumstances of the disclosure. A contract makes the claim easier to run and can provide extra remedies, but its absence is not fatal.
  • Once the information is public, it is fair game: Not necessarily. A combination of public materials can still be confidential, and the springboard doctrine means a recipient who built a head start from confidential information can be restrained even after it becomes public.
  • Breach of confidence works like a patent or copyright: It does not. It is not a registered right, there are no formalities and no register to search. It protects information, not ideas in the abstract, and the information must be identified with specificity.
  • The Privacy Act covers my business secrets: It does not. The Privacy Act 1988 (Cth) protects personal information about individuals. Commercial secrets such as recipes, customer lists and pricing structures are a different category and fall outside it.

Where a lawyer can help

Breach of confidence claims are often won and lost before any hearing, and a lawyer's value sits mostly at the front end.

Before a dispute arises, a lawyer can help you identify what information in your business is genuinely confidential and put in place the confidentiality agreements, employment contract clauses and access controls that make future claims provable. A well-drafted confidentiality clause can also do something equity cannot: it can define the information, set the scope of permitted use and survive the end of the relationship.

Once you suspect a leak, speed matters. A lawyer can assess whether you have an arguable claim, help you identify the precise information at issue, and apply for urgent interlocutory orders to stop the misuse while the matter is investigated. The remedies a court can order include injunctions to stop further use, equitable compensation for your loss, an account of the profits the recipient made from the misuse, and orders for delivery up or destruction of the material. In Del Casale the court permanently restrained the former employees and ordered an account of profits.

There can also be statutory claims running alongside the equitable one. Under s 183 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), a person who obtains information because they are, or have been, a director, officer or employee of a company must not improperly use it to gain an advantage for themselves or someone else, or to cause detriment to the company. That duty continues after the person leaves the company. A lawyer can tell you which claims you actually have, what evidence you need and whether an urgent application is warranted.

The question that decides your claim

Every breach of confidence claim comes down to a single practical question you should be able to answer about your own business: can you write down, in a sentence or two, exactly what information was misused and how the recipient came to hold it? Claims fail when they never get past this point. If you cannot name the information with precision, or cannot point to the circumstances in which it was shared, no amount of frustration about a former employee or a rival will move a court. If you can, you already hold the skeleton of the claim, and a lawyer can help you build the rest.