- The moment the choice lands
- Your two options
- Who wears the debts if the trust cannot pay
- What it costs to set up and run
- What happens when the trustee steps down
- How cleanly the records separate
- Tax treatment: what changes and what does not
- How an Artificer Legal lawyer helps you make the call
- The cost of getting the trustee wrong
The moment the choice lands
Your accountant has finished modelling the numbers and slides a draft trust deed across the desk with one box still to fill in: the trustee. Or the family trust your parents set up has an individual trustee who is now in their late seventies, and the estate planning conversation has turned to who takes over. Or you are restructuring a trading business and have been told the company that owns the premises should hand them to a trust, which needs a trustee before it can hold anything. Each of these moments lands on the same decision: whether the trustee should be a person or a company.
This is not a formality. The trustee is the party who holds legal title to everything the trust owns and who is personally on the hook if the trust's debts cannot be met. Getting the choice wrong is one of the more expensive mistakes a family or small business can make, because it is usually discovered years later, when a debt, a dispute or a death forces the issue.
Your two options
Australian trust law offers two basic choices of trustee: one or more individuals, or a company, commonly called a corporate trustee. Either can administer a discretionary trust, a unit trust or a fixed trust, and either holds the trust assets for the beneficiaries under the terms of the trust deed. The ATO describes a trust as an obligation imposed on a person or other entity to hold property for the benefit of beneficiaries, and notes that the trustee may be a person or a company, provided the trustee is legally capable of holding the trust property.
The real question is not which option is better in the abstract. It is whether the extra cost and formality of a company is worth it for the assets this trust will hold, the debts it might incur and the people standing behind it. Most advisers land on a similar framing: a corporate trustee is the safer default for a family or trading trust, while an individual trustee is workable mainly for small, low-risk, low-activity trusts where the extra structure would be disproportionate.
Before weighing the factors, three assumptions deserve to be flagged. First, the trust itself cannot be the trustee. A trust is a relationship, not a legal entity, so a person or company always has to stand behind it and wear the trustee's liability. Second, using an existing trading company as trustee is an option that looks convenient and is usually a mistake. A company with its own trading history, creditors and liabilities brings those problems into the trust. Best practice is a new company incorporated solely to act as trustee, with no assets, debts or history of its own. Third, the trustee is not the ultimate controller of the trust. That role belongs to the appointor, the person named in the deed with the power to appoint and remove the trustee. A corporate trustee does not hand control to the company. The appointor keeps the removal power either way, and the family usually controls the corporate trustee through its shares and directorships.
Who wears the debts if the trust cannot pay
This is the factor that usually decides the question, because it is where the two options differ most sharply.
Under Australian trust law, a trustee is personally liable for the debts of the trust they administer. The ATO states this directly: trustees are personally liable for the debts of the trusts they administer, and are entitled to be indemnified out of the trust property for liabilities incurred in the proper exercise of their powers, except where a breach of trust has occurred. The High Court reached the same position in Vacuum Oil Co Pty Ltd v Wiltshire [1945] HCA 37, where a trustee who contracted in the course of administering a trust was held personally liable to the creditor, with recourse only by way of indemnity against the trust assets. In Octavo Investments Pty Ltd v Knight [1979] HCA 61, the High Court added that the trustee's right of indemnity operates as a charge over the trust assets that ranks ahead of the beneficiaries' interests.
What this means in practice depends on who the trustee is:
- Individual trustee: The trustee's own assets sit behind the trust's debts. If the trust assets are insufficient, creditors can pursue the individual trustee personally, and a trustee who cannot pay can be made bankrupt. Indemnity clauses in a trust deed can shift some of that exposure, but they do not stop a creditor from suing the trustee first.
- Corporate trustee: A company is a separate legal entity that comes into existence on registration under s 119 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) and has the legal capacity of an individual under s 124. Creditors of the trust can pursue the company, but the company's shareholders are not on the hook beyond any amount unpaid on their shares, by virtue of s 516. Directors are not liable for the company's debts merely because they are directors.
The protection is real but it has limits. Directors who let the trustee company trade while insolvent can face personal liability for insolvent trading under s 588G of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). Lenders routinely ask directors to sign personal guarantees before extending credit to a trust, which can put the family home back on the line regardless of the structure. And the corporate shield only works if the company holds little beyond the trust assets. A company that trades in its own right, or carries debts from earlier activities, defeats the purpose of the structure.
What it costs to set up and run
An individual trustee costs almost nothing to appoint. The trust deed names them, and the trust still needs a tax file number and annual tax return, but there is no registration step and no annual fee.
A corporate trustee involves real but modest costs. Registering a proprietary company with ASIC costs $611 for the 2025-26 financial year, rising to $636 from 1 July 2026 under ASIC's annual indexation. The annual review fee for a proprietary company is $329 for 2025-26, rising to $342 from 1 July 2026. These figures come from ASIC's published fee schedule, which is indexed each 1 July in line with CPI. On top of the ASIC fees sit the practical costs: a company bank account, a separate company tax return, the annual review lodgement and the accountant's time in maintaining the structure.
For a trust holding a home, an investment portfolio or a trading business, this premium is small relative to what sits behind the structure. For a trust holding a single modest asset with no foreseeable debts, the annual fees can start to look disproportionate. This is the trade-off to weigh against the liability factor above.
What happens when the trustee steps down
Trusts are intended to outlive their founders, and the trustee rarely lasts as long as the trust does. The two options differ sharply on what happens when it is time for a change.
With an individual trustee, death, incapacity, bankruptcy or resignation all trigger a change of trustee. The new trustee must be appointed under the mechanism in the trust deed, and legal title to every trust asset must be transferred from the outgoing trustee to the incoming one. In a deceased estate, the delay can stretch for months while probate runs. Transfers of assets between trustees can also raise state duty and tax questions, and the outgoing trustee's personal estate remains exposed to claims that arose during their trusteeship.
With a corporate trustee, the company itself continues as the same legal entity. If the people behind the trust change, the directors and shareholders can be replaced while the company remains trustee, and no trust asset changes hands. That makes succession planning considerably cleaner: the trust deed and the company's registers can be arranged so that control of the trustee company passes smoothly to the next generation, and the appointor role can be structured with its own succession provisions. The one caveat is that none of this works unless the trust deed permits the change, which is why the deed's appointment and removal clauses deserve scrutiny at the outset.
How cleanly the records separate
The liability protection described above only holds up in practice if trust assets can be distinguished from the trustee's own assets. This is where individual trustees most often come unstuck.
An individual trustee holds trust property in their own name, with the words "as trustee" appended. When the same person has personal bank accounts, property and debts, the line between personal and trust assets blurs. If records are sloppy, it can be hard to show creditors, a court or the tax office which assets belong to the trust and which belong to the individual, and hard for the individual to prove that a liability was incurred in a trustee capacity. The ATO's warning that trustees must keep trust affairs separate from their own is a practical reflection of this problem.
A corporate trustee draws the line in the name itself. The company's bank accounts, contracts and invoices are all in the company's name, commonly expressed as "XYZ Pty Ltd ATF the Family Trust", and the company has no personal assets of its own to confuse with the trust's. This is an administration point rather than a legal one, but it is the difference between asset protection that works and asset protection that exists only on paper.
Tax treatment: what changes and what does not
The choice of trustee does not change who pays tax on trust income. The ATO's guidance is that beneficiaries are generally taxed on the net income of a trust based on their share of the trust's income, whether or not it is actually paid to them. That principle applies regardless of whether the trustee is an individual or a company.
What matters more is how the trust is administered. Income of a discretionary trust that is not distributed to beneficiaries in a given year is taxed in the trustee's hands at the top marginal rate under s 99A of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth), so the annual distribution resolution is a fixture of running a discretionary trust. The settlor, the person who establishes the trust with a nominal settlement sum, is typically excluded from benefiting, in part because s 102 of the same Act can expose trust income to special tax treatment where the settlor retains a power to revoke or benefit from the trust. Two further points are worth raising with a tax adviser rather than resolving here: some states apply different land tax thresholds or surcharges to land held in trusts, and capital gains tax concessions such as the main residence exemption are harder to access through a trust structure. None of these turn on the individual or corporate identity of the trustee, but they shape whether a trust is the right vehicle at all.
One related structure is worth knowing about. It is common for a family to combine a corporate trustee with a separate corporate beneficiary, sometimes called a bucket company, which receives distributions taxed at the corporate rate. That is a tax-planning decision about beneficiaries, not about trustees, and it is modelled on the facts of each family's situation.
How an Artificer Legal lawyer helps you make the call
The trustee decision is straightforward to describe and surprisingly easy to get wrong in the detail, which is where a lawyer earns their fee. An Artificer Legal practitioner would start by reading the trust deed and mapping its appointment, removal and indemnity clauses, because the deed is the document that actually governs who can be trustee and how a change happens. They would then stress-test the assumptions behind the choice: whether the asset protection a corporate trustee promises is real for this trust, given how the trust will trade, who will lend to it and who will be asked to guarantee its debts.
If a corporate trustee is the right call, the work is drafting and lodging the company constitution, arranging the ASIC registration and the company's tax identifiers, and making sure the deed, the company and the bank accounts are all aligned. If the trust already exists with an individual trustee, the lawyer can draft the deed of appointment of the new trustee and manage the transfer or vesting of trust assets, while flagging any duty or tax consequences of the change. Estate planning is part of the same conversation: who will hold the shares and the appointor role after the current generation, and how control passes without disrupting the trust.
The cost of getting the trustee wrong
The detail people most often get wrong is treating the trustee as paperwork. The trustee is the entity whose own assets stand behind the trust's debts, and every trust must have one. For most family and trading trusts, a corporate trustee is the safer default, but only if it is a fresh company that does nothing else, backed by a deed that deals sensibly with control, and run with records that keep the trust's assets visibly separate. An individual trustee remains a legitimate choice for small, low-risk trusts, provided the person understands they are personally exposed and the deed's indemnities are drafted to protect them.
The key points are these. The trustee holds legal title and is personally liable for the trust's debts, with a right of indemnity against trust assets. A corporate trustee contains that liability within a company, at the price of registration and annual fees. The appointor controls the trust either way, by holding the power to appoint and remove the trustee. Changes of trustee are administratively heavier with an individual, and the tax treatment of the trust does not turn on which kind of trustee it has. Whichever way the decision falls, it deserves to be made deliberately, with the deed read and the numbers modelled, before the trust starts operating.