1. "Today only" sales that run all month
  2. "From $X" prices most customers cannot get
  3. Mandatory fees revealed only at checkout
  4. A "free" offer with strings attached
  5. A quote that leaves out a key assumption
  6. A product claim that exceeds the evidence
  7. "Certified", "accredited" and "approved" without the credential
  8. Testimonials presented as typical results
  9. Sales scripts that guarantee outcomes
  10. Silence when the customer has the wrong idea
  11. The pattern across these examples
  12. What to check before you publish
  13. When you should get advice before the claim goes out
  14. The test that decides every one of these examples

Every marketing claim, quote, sales script and product description a small business sends out is conduct under Australian law. Most of it is harmless. Some of it creates a legal risk the business never intended, because the test for misleading or deceptive conduct does not ask whether anyone meant to deceive. It asks what impression the conduct actually created.

That test comes from s 18 of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) (the ACL), which prohibits a person in trade or commerce from engaging in conduct that is misleading or deceptive, or likely to mislead or deceive. The prohibition applies to businesses dealing with consumers and with other businesses. There is no requirement of intention, and the question is judged objectively: would a reasonable member of the audience the conduct was directed at be led into error? Courts assess the overall impression the conduct conveys, not individual sentences in isolation, and they do so from the standpoint of the audience the conduct was aimed at, whether that is a consumer market or a handful of business buyers. The examples below show where that line has fallen in practice, so you can spot the same patterns in your own advertising, pricing and sales materials before they become a complaint.

"Today only" sales that run all month

A business advertises a discount as "today only" or "ends midnight", then keeps the same promotion running for weeks, or repeats the urgency claim every month. The price may be genuinely discounted, but the claim that creates the urgency is not true. Because a reasonable customer relies on the time limit to decide to buy now, the false urgency can be enough on its own to make the promotion misleading, even though the discount itself is real.

"From $X" prices most customers cannot get

A service is advertised "from $199", but that figure applies only to a narrow subset of jobs, or requires conditions the customer does not meet, and most customers pay far more. The advertised price is not the point of the example: the point is what the reasonable customer takes away, which is the price they will pay. When the "from" price is not genuinely available for a reasonable proportion of customers, the overall impression is misleading. The safe practice is to state what the price depends on, such as size, scope or inclusions, wherever the "from" price appears.

Mandatory fees revealed only at checkout

A product is promoted at a headline price, and compulsory charges such as a booking fee, admin fee or processing fee appear only in the final checkout step. The customer has already committed to the purchase in their mind, and the advertised price is not the price they can actually pay. The ACL has specific rules about how prices must be displayed, including that a single total price must be shown in most circumstances and that any claim about a price must state the total. Presenting a headline price while burying unavoidable fees until the last step is a classic way to make the headline price misleading, and it is one of the pricing practices regulators actively chase.

A "free" offer with strings attached

A "free trial" requires a non-refundable setup payment, or converts automatically into a paid subscription without a clear upfront disclosure. The word "free" is doing the misleading work: a reasonable customer understands free to mean no payment obligation, and a charge they did not expect undercuts that impression. The fix is not to remove the word from the vocabulary, but to put any conditions immediately beside the offer, not in fine print a page away.

A quote that leaves out a key assumption

A builder quotes a "bathroom renovation" without stating that waterproofing is excluded, and the customer later faces a large extra charge for it. Nothing in the quote is literally false. But the overall impression, assessed against what a reasonable customer would assume a bathroom renovation includes, is that the quoted amount covers the job. This is why disputes over quotes so often turn on the objective test rather than on what was said in a phone call: the reasonable interpretation of the document is what counts.

A product claim that exceeds the evidence

A skincare brand describes a moisturiser as "medical-grade" and "clinically proven" on the strength of a small internal survey, and a hearing aid advertiser runs ads suggesting pensioners can obtain free devices through a government program when the reality was more limited. In Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Oticon Australia Pty Ltd [2018] FCA 1826, the Federal Court recorded admitted contraventions of s 18 and related provisions for precisely this kind of advertising, and penalties were imposed with an eye to deterrence. The pattern is the same in both cases: the claim implies a level of performance or approval the evidence, or the actual terms of the offer, does not support.

"Certified", "accredited" and "approved" without the credential

A tradie displays an industry badge on the website, or a consultant describes themselves as "certified" in a method, when the qualification is held by an employee who left, or the certification is in something different from what customers would reasonably understand. Credentials are powerful precisely because customers rely on them as independent verification. Holding out a credential you do not hold, or describing it loosely, is the kind of representation that misleads regardless of whether the underlying service is perfectly good.

Testimonials presented as typical results

A fitness business publishes a client's dramatic transformation as the face of the program, when the program's average results are far more modest, and a review service hosts a "5-star" testimonial from a customer who never existed. Testimonials are treated as representations about what other customers have experienced. A fabricated review is a false representation, and an exceptional result presented without qualification as what customers can expect creates the same problem: it leads the reasonable reader to expect an outcome that is not typical.

Sales scripts that guarantee outcomes

A salesperson tells a customer "you will definitely be approved" for a loan, or "this will solve your problem", when approval depends on a third party and the outcome is uncertain. Statements like these create a representation about the future that the business cannot make good on. A promise of a future outcome is misleading if the person making it has no reasonable basis for the promise. The same applies to statements that are true only in part, like "you can cancel any time" when the contract requires 30 days' notice and a termination fee, or a sales pitch that relies on a "subject to assessment" condition the customer only discovers after they have signed. The oral promise and the written condition are judged together, and the promise is the part the customer remembers.

Silence when the customer has the wrong idea

A customer asks whether a product includes installation, and the salesperson answers vaguely, knowing the customer believes it does. The business has not said anything untrue, but s 18 can capture what is left unsaid when a reasonable customer would be led into error by the silence. Staying silent to avoid losing the sale is the quiet version of the same conduct the other examples show: the impression that survives in the customer's mind is what the law judges.

The pattern across these examples

None of these scenarios requires a lie, and none requires an intention to deceive. What they share is a gap between the impression the customer reasonably takes away and the reality of the offer. The impression can be created by a headline, a photo, a price, a credential, a testimonial, a salesperson's promise, or an omission that was never corrected. Wherever the gap opens, the conduct is judged by the impression, not by the intention.

What to check before you publish

Before any ad, quote, script or landing page goes out, run it through this checklist:

  • Run the overall impression test: Read your ad, quote or landing page as a customer who knows nothing else about the business, and ask what they would believe after reading it once. That belief, not your intention, is what a court would assess.
  • Assume disclaimers do not rescue a headline: A qualification buried in fine print does not correct an impression created by the headline. If the reasonable reader takes the wrong meaning from the headline, the disclaimer will not fix it. Put conditions where they change the impression, not where they hide it.
  • Treat pricing as the highest-risk area: "From" prices, mandatory fees, and quotes that assume rather than state are the most common triggers of complaints. If a customer could be surprised by the final cost, the surprise is the risk.
  • Make sure staff and contractors say what you would say: A business is responsible for what its employees say in sales calls, messages and counter conversations. Approved language for common questions, and an escalation path for unusual ones, costs little and prevents the expensive version of this problem.
  • Keep the evidence for your claims: If you make a performance, certification or testimonial claim, keep the testing, credentials or customer records that support it. The claim is only as safe as the basis you can produce for it.

When you should get advice before the claim goes out

Some claims are worth a quick professional review before they are published, because the cost of getting them wrong is far higher than the cost of the review. That includes campaigns built on superlative claims, pricing structures with "from" prices or mandatory fees, offers promoted as free or limited, and any customer-facing contract or policy that staff will repeat to customers. A lawyer would look at your actual materials, identify the impression each one is likely to create for a reasonable customer in your market, and tell you where the gap is between that impression and what you can deliver or evidence. They can also review whether your terms, refund policy and advertising language are consistent with each other, since inconsistency between what staff promise and what the contract says is a recurring source of disputes. And if a complaint or a regulator inquiry has already arrived, the first steps you take can significantly affect the outcome, which is another situation where professional advice early is cheaper than professional advice late.

The test that decides every one of these examples

Ask what a reasonable customer would believe after seeing the whole message, including what is implied, what is left out and what is buried in the fine print. That belief is the conduct that the law judges, and every example in this article crossed the line only because that belief did not match the reality. If you can look at your own material and see the mismatch before a customer does, you have found the risk while it is still cheap to fix.

Misleading conduct under the ACL is an objective test with no intent requirement, it applies to claims made in advertising, pricing, quotes, sales conversations and even silence, and it turns on the overall impression a reasonable customer would take away. The practical protection is simple: state the important conditions where the customer will see them, keep evidence for every claim you make, and treat the customer's reasonable understanding as the version of the truth that counts.