Most people who buy an NFT believe they have bought the artwork itself. In Australian law, that is usually not what has happened. The token you hold in your wallet and the copyright in the image, music, video or code behind it are two separate things, and only one of them changes hands when an NFT is sold.
That gap between what buyers think they own and what the law says they own is where most NFT disputes start. This guide explains how copyright attaches to NFTs under the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth), who owns what by default, how rights are transferred through licences and assignments, why moral rights complicate things, and where the scheme most often bites for creators and projects.
The two layers: the token and the copyright
An NFT is a record on a blockchain. It has a unique token identifier, is held in a digital wallet, and usually points to, or contains, a digital file such as an image, a music track, a video or a piece of code. What the blockchain records is who controls that token identifier, not who holds the legal rights in the file it points to.
Copyright is a separate bundle of exclusive rights that the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) gives in original creative works. It covers things like copying the work, publishing it, communicating it to the public online and making adaptations of it. Those rights exist independently of any blockchain, and they are owned by a person, not held in a wallet.
So when someone mints an NFT, two layers are created at once:
- The token layer: who controls the token in their wallet, recorded on the blockchain.
- The content layer: who owns the copyright in the artwork, audio, video, text or code, which is a question of contract and statute.
Buying the token transfers only the token layer, unless the seller also grants rights in the content layer. Under s 196(1) of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth), copyright is personal property that can be transferred by assignment, by will or by devolution by operation of law. A transfer does not happen automatically when a token changes hands, and it certainly does not happen by implication. It happens only through a documented licence or assignment, or through one of the ownership rules in the Act.
Who owns the copyright by default
The starting point is s 35(2) of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth): the author of an original literary, dramatic, musical or artistic work is the owner of the copyright in it. For most NFT projects, that means the artist, musician, developer or studio that created the content owns the copyright unless a written agreement changes the position.
There are two important qualifications to that default rule.
First, s 35(6) provides that where a work is made by an author in the course of employment under a contract of service or apprenticeship, the employer owns the copyright. If your in-house designer creates the artwork as part of their job, your company owns the copyright. But s 35(3) allows the operation of these rules to be varied by agreement, so the employment contract still matters.
Second, the employee exception does not cover contractors, freelancers or collaborators. A contractor who produces art for your project keeps the copyright unless they sign an assignment or licence that transfers or permits the use you need. This is the single most common ownership gap in NFT projects: the studio assumes it owns everything, while the freelance artist still holds the copyright and can stop the mint or demand terms.
The people in the room: creators, holders and marketplaces
Three groups interact around every NFT collection, and each has a different relationship to the copyright:
- Creators and projects: own the copyright by default and decide what rights, if any, to grant to buyers.
- Buyers and holders: receive the token and whatever licence the project grants. Their rights come from the project's terms, not from owning the token.
- Marketplaces: facilitate minting and resale. Their terms are contractual, and their royalty settings and licence displays are commercial arrangements, not sources of copyright.
The tension sits between the first two groups. Creators want to control how their art is used to preserve the value of the collection, while buyers want freedom to use, display and sometimes monetise what they hold. The law does not resolve that tension. The project's licence does, which is why the drafting of that licence is the heart of any NFT project.
Licence or assignment: what a buyer actually gets
There are two mechanisms under the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) for giving a buyer rights in the content behind a token, and they are very different.
Licence
A licence is permission to use the work in defined ways while ownership stays with the creator. A project can grant a personal, non-commercial licence, which lets a holder display the art as a profile picture but nothing more. It can grant limited commercial rights, such as permission to sell merchandise featuring the art up to a revenue cap. Or it can grant full commercial rights, or even release the art into the public domain through a Creative Commons or CC0 style waiver.
The licence should be written and accessible to buyers at mint or purchase. Its scope should cover what the holder may do, what they may not do, whether they can sublicense, whether revenue caps apply, and whether community standards such as no hate speech or no illegal use are imposed. Under s 196(4) of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth), a licence granted by the copyright owner binds every successor in title to the copyright. That means a project that later assigns its copyright still has to honour the licences it already granted to holders, which is worth remembering before anyone sells the collection's IP.
Assignment
An assignment transfers ownership of the copyright itself, in whole or in part. Under s 196(3) of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth), an assignment has no effect unless it is in writing and signed by or on behalf of the assignor. A statement in marketing copy, a Discord announcement or a smart contract event is not enough on its own.
Assignments can also be partial. Section 196(2) allows an assignment to be limited to particular classes of rights, to a place in Australia, or to part of the copyright period. A project could, for example, assign the right to reproduce the artwork for merchandise while keeping the right to mint new tokens. That precision is useful, but it also means an assignment needs to say exactly what is being transferred.
If you intend to sell the copyright with each NFT, your sales flow needs a valid assignment instrument, usually presented as a written document that the buyer accepts during mint or purchase. Most projects keep copyright and grant a licence instead, because that preserves brand control across the collection. A smaller number assign copyright outright, and a few give holders commercial rights while keeping copyright with the project, which is a licence dressed in ambitious language.
Moral rights: what cannot be sold
Even an assignment of copyright does not strip the creator of everything. Part IX of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) gives authors three moral rights: the right of attribution, the right not to have authorship falsely attributed, and the right of integrity, which protects against derogatory treatment of the work.
Section 195AN(3) is explicit that a moral right is not transmissible by assignment, by will or by devolution by operation of law. The creator keeps their moral rights even after the copyright is assigned, which matters for NFT projects in two ways. First, holders and the project itself should attribute the artist wherever the work is used. Second, treatment of the art that the artist considers derogatory, such as heavy modification or use in offensive contexts, can infringe the right of integrity even if the buyer owns the copyright.
The Act does allow for consent. Under s 195AWA, it is not an infringement of a moral right to do something within the scope of a written consent genuinely given by the author, provided the consent is given in relation to specified acts or omissions and specified works. A well-drafted holder licence should address attribution up front and include any moral rights consents the project needs, particularly if the project plans to modify or reuse the art.
Royalties: on-chain settings and the statutory scheme
On-chain royalties are a commercial setting, not a copyright right. When a marketplace deducts a creator royalty on resale, it is enforcing a configuration chosen by the project, not a legal entitlement. Marketplaces can and do change their royalty policies, so projects should not rely on them. The licence between the project and the buyer can still require resale royalties as a matter of contract, and should explain how they are calculated and what happens if a marketplace does not pay them automatically.
There is also a genuine statutory royalty in Australia that projects dealing in digital art should know about. The Resale Royalty Right for Visual Artists Act 2009 (Cth) gives visual artists a royalty on commercial resales of their original works. The definition of an artwork in s 7 expressly includes digital artworks, multimedia artworks and video artworks, which brings digital art within the scheme's language. A commercial resale under s 8 is a transfer of ownership for monetary consideration that is not the first transfer, and that involves an art market professional such as an auctioneer, art dealer or gallery operator. Section 20 makes the seller, any art market professional acting as agent, and in some cases the buyer, liable to pay the royalty.
Whether a particular NFT resale triggers this scheme is an open question. The scheme was built around transfers of ownership of artworks, and an NFT sale transfers a token, not necessarily the artwork itself. If your project deals in digital art, or if you are a digital artist watching your work resell for large sums, it is worth having a lawyer assess whether the scheme applies to your sales and who owes what.
Where the scheme bites: trouble spots for NFT projects
The rules are straightforward until real projects apply them. These are the situations where the gap between the token layer and the content layer usually causes problems.
Multiple contributors and commissioned work
If your art, music, code or storylines come from a team of contractors or collaborators, clarify ownership before you mint. Employees transfer ownership through s 35(6), but contractors do not. You need written assignments or licences from every contributor, and those documents must be consistent with the licence you intend to grant holders. A contributor who keeps their copyright can later object to uses you assumed were covered.
AI-generated content
Copyright protects original works, and Australian law has not yet settled how works generated by artificial intelligence tools are treated for copyright purposes, including whether there is a human author and, if so, who owns the output. If your collection relies on AI-generated elements, document the tools used and the chain of rights, and take advice before you promise buyers any ownership or usage rights in that content.
Third-party IP
Never mint content you do not own or have rights to use. Stock images, music samples, brand logos and celebrity likenesses all come with their own rights, and the licences you hold for other purposes may not extend to blockchain minting, distribution and resale. Misusing third-party IP invites takedowns and damages claims, and records of permissions and assignments matter when you need to prove your chain of title.
Marketing claims and consumer law
Statements about what buyers get are regulated. Section 18 of the Australian Consumer Law, which sits in Schedule 2 of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), prohibits misleading or deceptive conduct in trade or commerce. Words like ownership, commercial rights and exclusive carry legal meaning, and if your marketing promises more than your licence delivers, you face exposure under the ACL as well as disappointed holders. Keep your site copy, Discord announcements and marketplace listings consistent with the actual licence.
Brand protection
Your project name and logo are often worth more over time than any single token, and copyright does not protect them in the same way. Registration under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) is the tool for that. Section 20 gives the registered owner exclusive rights to use the mark and to authorise others to use it for the registered goods and services, plus a statutory remedy for infringement. Filing for your name and key logos before a public mint gives you a practical way to stop fake mints and copycat collections.
When a lawyer earns their fee
Much of this can be handled with good documents, but there are points in the life of a collection where professional help pays for itself.
Before mint, a lawyer can run an IP clearance check over every asset, secure written assignments from contributors, and help you decide the rights model. The choice between personal use, limited commercial, full commercial and outright assignment drives every document that follows, and it is much cheaper to decide it once than to renegotiate it after holders have bought in.
At drafting time, a lawyer prepares the holder licence, any assignment instruments, and the platform terms that make those documents binding at purchase. The technical requirements of s 196(3) and s 195AWA are easy to miss in a self-drafted terms page, and a missed signature or an overbroad consent can invalidate the rights you think you granted.
Later, a lawyer helps when things go wrong: responding to takedowns, defending or pursuing infringement claims, dealing with royalty disputes, or reviewing marketing for consumer law exposure. Trade mark filing strategy is also worth doing early, because a local filing can be the cheapest insurance against copycats while you grow.
The mint is where the rights model is set
Everything in this article converges on a single moment: the first mint. The decisions made before that mint, who owns each asset, what licence holders receive, whether any assignment occurs, what the marketing promises, determine the legal shape of the collection for its entire life. Fixing ownership gaps after the fact means chasing signatures from contributors who may have moved on, and explaining to angry holders why the rights they thought they bought are not what the law gives them.
The documents themselves are inexpensive compared with the disputes they prevent. A written licence or assignment is a small line item in a project budget, while an ownership fight over a successful collection can consume the project. If you are about to mint, or have already minted without documented rights, a short consultation can map where the gaps are before they become someone else's lawyer's fee. Most firms, including ours, offer a free initial conversation, and knowing the two layers is the difference between a collection built on a token and one built on rights that actually hold up.