- The settlor is the one-off creator of a trust
- Who does what: the roles inside a typical trust
- The three certainties: what the law requires before a trust exists
- Why the settlor should be independent
- When trusts form differently: testamentary and unit trusts
- After settlement: registration, tax and the paper trail
- Where lawyers and accountants come in
- The settlement moment is the trust's weakest point
The settlor is the one-off creator of a trust
When a family discretionary trust, unit trust or other inter vivos trust is established in Australia, it needs someone to create it. That person is the settlor: the individual (or occasionally a company) who executes the trust deed with the initial trustee and transfers the first property into the trust, usually a nominal cash amount sometimes called the settlement sum.
The role exists because of a basic rule of trust law: a trust cannot float into existence on intention alone. Property must be put into the hands of a trustee to hold for identified beneficiaries on clear terms. The settlor is the person who performs that act of creation, and in most cases their involvement is over almost as soon as it begins. Everything after settlement, the management of assets, the making of distributions and the running of the trust's tax affairs, belongs to the trustee.
Getting the settlor role right matters more than its brevity suggests. The choice of who acts as settlor, whether the settlement is actually made and evidenced, and how the deed is executed all shape the trust's exposure to tax review, creditor attack and family dispute for decades afterwards. This guide explains how the creation of a trust works in practice, what the settlor does at each step, and where the role usually goes wrong.
Who does what: the roles inside a typical trust
A trust is not a separate legal entity like a company. It is a relationship, recognised by equity, under which one person holds property for the benefit of others. Four roles recur in almost every Australian trust, and it helps to see them side by side:
- Settlor: Creates the trust by executing the deed and making the initial transfer of property to the trustee. Takes no part in running the trust afterwards.
- Trustee: Holds legal title to the trust property and manages it for the beneficiaries. The trustee can be an individual or a company, and is personally liable for the trust's debts (with a right of indemnity out of trust assets). Under tax law the trustee is responsible for the trust's registrations, returns and some tax liabilities.
- Beneficiaries: The people or entities entitled to income or capital. In a discretionary trust they are named, or described as a class, in the deed and only become entitled when the trustee exercises a discretion in their favour. The trustee may also be a beneficiary, but not the sole beneficiary unless there is more than one trustee.
- Appointor (also called principal or guardian): Not a statutory role, but a common drafting feature. The appointor holds the power to remove and appoint trustees, which in a family trust is often the real control lever, sitting with a parent or family company rather than the trustee.
The ATO summarises the trustee's position simply: where the trust is established by deed (which, in the case of a deceased estate, is the will), the trustee must deal with the trust property in line with the intentions of the settlor as set out in the deed. That is the settlor's one lasting footprint: their intentions, recorded in the deed, bind everyone who comes after.
The three certainties: what the law requires before a trust exists
Before the settlor's actions mean anything, the proposed trust must satisfy what Australian courts call the three certainties. As the High Court confirmed in Byrnes v Kendle (2011) 243 CLR 253, adopting a formulation long applied in Australia, the intention to create a trust must be clear, it must be clear what property is subject to the trust, and it must be reasonably certain who the beneficiaries are.
Two points about certainty of intention are worth understanding, because they explain why the deed is drafted with care. First, intention is assessed objectively. The question is what the settlor did and said, not what they privately meant. In Byrnes v Kendle the High Court held that a written declaration of trust is conclusive as to intention in the absence of fraud, duress, mistake or a sham, and that evidence of a settlor's unexpressed mental reservations cannot displace it. Second, the other two certainties do real work. A trust over vague or unidentifiable property, or for beneficiaries that cannot be ascertained, is not a trust at all.
The deed alone, however, is not the whole story. For a trust to be completely constituted, the settlor must actually vest the property in the trustee. This is the rule from Milroy v Lord (1862) 45 ER 1185, applied in Australia in Corin v Patton (1990) 169 CLR 540: to make a voluntary settlement valid and effectual, the settlor must do everything that, according to the nature of the property, is necessary to transfer it and render the settlement binding. Equity will not perfect an imperfect gift. An executed deed with no transfer behind it leaves beneficiaries with nothing they can compel, which is precisely why the nominal settlement exists.
What the settlor does, step by step
For an ordinary inter vivos trust, the settlor's involvement has three steps.
Step one: execute the trust deed with the initial trustee
The deed records the terms on which the trust operates: the beneficiaries or class of beneficiaries, the trustee's powers, the distribution rules, who can appoint and remove trustees, and when the trust vests. The settlor signs it alongside the initial trustee. Because the trust deed is a deed and not a simple contract, it must be executed with the formalities that apply to deeds, which differ depending on the state or territory governing the deed, whether the trustee is an individual or a company, and whether execution is on paper or electronically.
Step two: make the initial transfer
The settlor transfers a small amount of property to the trustee to hold on the deed's terms, usually cash of $10 or a similar nominal sum. This is the moment the trust is constituted: property now sits in the trustee's hands for the beneficiaries, satisfying the subject matter requirement alongside the deed's expression of intention and objects. In a unit trust the same function is often performed by the proceeds of the initial issue of units rather than a token settlement.
Step three: step away
After settlement the settlor's role is finished. They hold no ongoing powers, make no decisions and receive no distributions unless the deed provides otherwise, and standard drafting practice is that it does not. From that point the trustee manages the trust, and the ATO holds the trustee responsible for registering the trust, lodging returns and paying tax.
The clean break is deliberate. Keeping the settlor separate from both control and benefit preserves the distinction that makes a trust work as a genuine arrangement for others, and it keeps the structure clear of the tax and challenge risks discussed next.
Why the settlor should be independent
There is no statute that says the settlor of a family trust cannot be a beneficiary, cannot act as trustee or cannot hold the role of appointor. The independence rule is a risk-management convention, and it is a strong one. Modern trust deeds routinely exclude the settlor from the class of beneficiaries for the reasons below.
The most concrete tax exposure sits in s 102 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth), headed "Revocable trusts". It applies where the person who created a trust retains a power to revoke or alter the trusts so as to acquire a beneficial interest in the trust income or property. In that situation the Commissioner may assess the trustee, and the practical effect is that the trust's income is taxed as if it were the settlor's own, at the settlor's marginal rate. The same section reaches income paid to or accumulated for the settlor's children under 18. A settlor who keeps a string attached to the settlement, or who can benefit from the trust, sits squarely in the territory this provision polices.
Beyond s 102, there is the sham risk. Australian courts will disregard documents that are a facade, where the true arrangement is that the property really belongs to and is controlled by the person who created the trust. The High Court addressed the meaning of sham in this context in Raftland Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (2008) 238 CLR 516. The more control and benefit the settlor keeps, the easier it becomes for the ATO, a creditor or a family member in a dispute to argue the trust was never a genuine arrangement for others. That argument, if it succeeds, collapses the very structure people set up trusts to achieve.
Independence also supports asset protection. If the settlor can benefit from or control the trust, the separation between the settlor's personal position and the trust's assets is blurred, and the trust property is more exposed to the settlor's creditors and personal liabilities. A truly independent settlor makes that attack much harder to run.
In practice, that means:
- Good candidates: an accountant or solicitor who is not a beneficiary and will not control the trust, a trusted friend or colleague with no interest in it, or an unrelated third party comfortable performing a one-off formality.
- People to avoid: anyone who is or could be a beneficiary (including close family members of a family trust), anyone who will act as trustee or appointor, and anyone who might later receive distributions or other benefits from the trust.
The paperwork around the role deserves the same care. Record the settlor's full name and address and the settlement details in the deed, keep a dated copy of the executed deed, and keep evidence of the actual transfer such as a bank record or receipt in the trust file. Do not later reimburse the settlement sum to the settlor; returning the money raises questions about whether the trust was ever genuinely constituted, and it invites the kind of scrutiny described above.
When trusts form differently: testamentary and unit trusts
Not every trust starts with a nominal settlement by a third party. Two variations are common enough to know about.
A testamentary trust is created by a will and takes effect on death. There is no separate settlor making a token transfer during life. The will itself performs the settling function, the trustee holds the estate assets for the beneficiaries on the will's terms, and the ATO treats the will as the trust's governing "deed" for these purposes. Testamentary trusts also attract different tax rules: income a minor receives from the investment of property that devolved from a deceased estate is excepted from the special rates that generally apply to children's trust income under Division 6AA of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth), which is why these structures are often used for blended families, disability planning and estate equalisation.
Unit trusts are constituted differently again. Instead of a token settlement, the trust is funded by investors subscribing for units, and the unit holders' capital becomes the initial trust property. A nominal settlement may still appear in the deed for technical completeness, but the real constitution happens through the unit subscriptions.
After settlement: registration, tax and the paper trail
Once the trust exists, the compliance load shifts to the trustee. The ATO's guidance for trustees sets out the essentials:
- Tax file number: a trust should have its own TFN, which the trustee uses when lodging the trust's tax returns.
- ABN: a trust is entitled to an ABN if it is carrying on an enterprise. The trustee registers for the TFN and ABN in their capacity as trustee, and the ABN is issued in the name "The Trustee for..." followed by the trust's name.
- GST: if the trust's current or projected GST turnover is $75,000 or more, GST registration is compulsory, and registration must happen within 21 days of crossing the threshold. The trustee needs an ABN before registering for GST.
- Returns: a trustee must lodge a trust tax return regardless of the amount of net income involved, unless the ATO advises a return is not required, and trusts that derive income are generally expected to lodge each year.
- Resolutions: for a discretionary trust, the trustee must make a resolution by 30 June each income year to make beneficiaries presently entitled to the trust's income, with separate requirements for capital gains and franked distributions.
Execution formalities deserve a mention here, because a deed that is not validly executed is a deed that never properly took effect. In New South Wales, for example, the Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW) requires every deed to be signed and sealed and attested by at least one witness who is not a party, and separately provides that a deed may be created in electronic form and electronically signed and attested. The rules in other states and territories, and for company trustees under the Corporations Act, are not identical, so confirm the position for the jurisdiction and parties involved before signing rather than assuming one rule applies everywhere.
Finally, keep the paper trail alive. The signed deed, the evidence of settlement, the trustee's minutes and resolutions, and the trust's tax records should all live in one file. When a trust is reviewed years later, whether by a bank, an auditor, the ATO or a court in a family dispute, the file is the trust's proof that it was real, constituted and properly run.
Where lawyers and accountants come in
The settlor's role is a one-off, but the decisions around it are made once and never again, which is why professional input at the start is disproportionately valuable. A lawyer drafting the deed sets the beneficiary classes, the trustee's powers and the appointor provisions, advises on who should act as settlor and appointor for the family's circumstances, and ensures the deed is executed with the correct formalities. A tax adviser handles the TFN, ABN and GST registrations, advises on whether settling anything other than cash (such as shares or property that has appreciated) creates its own tax consequences at the time of settlement, and keeps the annual resolution and return cycle on track.
Most of the costly failures in this area, an unconstituted trust, a settlor with strings attached, a deed executed informally, are cheap to prevent and expensive to unpick. A structure that is defective at inception usually cannot be rescued by paperwork later; in the worst cases the only fix is a new trust, with new stamp duty, new registrations and a new deed.
The settlement moment is the trust's weakest point
If there is one thing to take from the settlor's role, it is this: the trust is only as strong as its moment of creation. The deed can be beautifully drafted, the beneficiary classes perfectly planned, but if the settlement was never actually made, or the settlor kept the power to take the property back, or the person who settled it is also the person who controls and benefits from it, the structure fails at exactly the time it is needed, when a creditor attacks, the ATO reviews, or a relationship breaks down.
None of that is hard to avoid. An independent settlor, a genuinely made and evidenced nominal settlement, and a properly executed deed cost nothing extra at setup. The difficulty is that the people establishing the trust rarely realise how much turns on these details until something goes wrong. A short conversation with a lawyer before the deed is signed, covering who should act as settlor, how the trust should be constituted and which formalities apply, closes off most of the risk, and it is far less expensive than rebuilding a trust that was defective from day one.