1. The players in the regime
  2. Who is protected: the small business test
  3. What counts as a standard form contract
  4. When is a term unfair
  5. Terms that cannot be challenged
  6. What happens when a term is found unfair
  7. Where the regime has bitten
  8. Common traps for businesses
  9. How a lawyer can help
  10. The real cost of an unreviewed template

Every business that trades on its own terms and conditions, a franchise agreement, a software licence or an online click-through contract has to work with the unfair contract terms rules. The Australian Consumer Law (ACL), which sits in Schedule 2 of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), has let courts strike out unfair terms in standard form consumer contracts since 2010 and extended the same protection to small businesses from 12 November 2016. On 9 November 2023 the regime changed again: proposing, using or relying on an unfair term is now prohibited conduct that can attract civil penalties of up to $100 million for a company, and the definition of a protected small business was widened substantially.

This article explains how the regime works end to end: who is protected, what makes a contract a standard form contract, when a term is unfair, what happens when a court finds one, and where the rules have bitten in practice.

The players in the regime

The regime involves five sets of players, each with a different role:

  • The small business: the party that enters a standard form contract in the course of its business and is protected by the rules.
  • The counterparty: usually the business that prepared the standard terms, such as a franchisor, a platform, a supplier or a landlord.
  • The regulators: the ACCC for goods and services generally, and ASIC for financial products and services, investigate and take enforcement action.
  • The courts: can declare a term unfair, make it void, and impose penalties and other remedies.
  • Lawyers: review standard form contracts, advise on whether terms are defensible, and respond to regulator inquiries.

Most of the tension sits between the small business and the counterparty. The counterparty wants one uniform, low-cost contract it can use across many customers. The small business wants terms that reflect its own circumstances. The regime exists because in a take-it-or-leave-it negotiation, the smaller party rarely gets what it wants.

Who is protected: the small business test

A contract is a small business contract for the purposes of the regime if it is for the supply of goods or services, or a sale or grant of an interest in land, and at least one party satisfies either of two tests (s 23(4) of the ACL):

  • Fewer than 100 employees: the party makes the contract in the course of carrying on a business and employs fewer than 100 people at the time the contract is made. Casual employees are counted only if they work on a regular and systematic basis, and part-time employees are counted as a fraction of a full-time equivalent.
  • Turnover under $10 million: the party's turnover for its last income year ending before the contract was made is less than $10 million, worked out on a GST basis.

The two tests are alternatives, so a business with 50 employees and a turnover of $50 million is protected, and so is a business with 200 employees and a turnover of $5 million. Only one party needs to qualify for the contract to be a small business contract.

Two further points matter. First, the earlier dollar caps on the value of the contract were removed from the ACL definition entirely in the 2023 reforms. Under the mirror provisions of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) (the ASIC Act), which cover financial products and services, a small business contract still requires an upfront price of $5 million or less.

Second, timing matters. The strengthened rules apply to standard form contracts made or renewed on or after 9 November 2023, and to any term varied or added on or after that date, as the ACCC explains in its guidance on contracts.

What counts as a standard form contract

The regime only applies to standard form contracts: pre-prepared contracts offered on a take-it-or-leave-it basis, where the customer can accept or reject but cannot meaningfully change the terms.

The law starts from a presumption. If a party alleges a contract is a standard form contract, it is presumed to be one unless the other party proves otherwise (s 27(1) of the ACL). In practice this puts the burden on the business that drafted the terms.

In deciding the question, a court must consider (s 27(2) of the ACL):

  • whether one party holds all or most of the bargaining power;
  • whether one party has made other contracts in the same or substantially similar terms, and how many;
  • whether the contract was prepared by one party before any discussion about the transaction occurred;
  • whether the other party was effectively required to accept or reject the terms in the form presented;
  • whether the other party had an effective opportunity to negotiate; and
  • whether the terms take into account the specific characteristics of the other party or the particular transaction.

Since 9 November 2023 the law has also made clear that a contract can still be a standard form contract even where the customer negotiated minor or insubstantial changes, selected a term from a range of options set by the other party, or negotiated a separate contract through a third party (s 27(3) of the ACL).

The practical upshot is that franchise agreements, software licences, trading terms and conditions, platform agreements, supplier agreements and membership terms are all commonly standard form contracts, even where some customers have managed small concessions.

When is a term unfair

A term of a standard form consumer or small business contract is unfair if three conditions are met (s 24(1) of the ACL):

  • it would cause a significant imbalance in the parties' rights and obligations under the contract;
  • it is not reasonably necessary to protect the legitimate interests of the party who would be advantaged by the term; and
  • it would cause detriment, financial or otherwise, to the other party if it were applied or relied on.

The advantaged party must prove that the term is reasonably necessary to protect its legitimate interests. If it cannot, the term is presumed not to be reasonably necessary (s 24(4) of the ACL).

A court must also take into account two further matters: the extent to which the term is transparent, and the contract as a whole (s 24(2) of the ACL). A term is transparent if it is expressed in reasonably plain language, is legible, is presented clearly, and is readily available to any party affected by it (s 24(3) of the ACL).

The Act lists examples of the kinds of terms that may be unfair (s 25 of the ACL), including terms that let one party, but not the other, terminate the contract, vary the terms, renew or not renew the contract, vary the upfront price without giving the other party a right to terminate, or penalise the other party for breach or termination. Unilateral variation clauses, automatic renewal clauses and one-sided termination rights are the most commonly challenged.

A term is not unfair simply because it favours one side. A termination right that protects a legitimate interest, such as ending a franchise agreement when the franchisee becomes insolvent, is likely to survive. The analysis always turns on the specific term, the contract as a whole and the surrounding circumstances.

Terms that cannot be challenged

Section 26 of the ACL shields certain terms from attack altogether. The rules do not apply to a term, to the extent that it:

  • defines the main subject matter of the contract;
  • sets the upfront price payable under the contract; or
  • is required, or expressly permitted, by a law of the Commonwealth, a state or a territory.

The price itself cannot be attacked as unfair, and neither can the core definition of what is being supplied. But terms around the price, such as clauses allowing unilateral price increases or charging for goods not ordered, are not protected.

What happens when a term is found unfair

There are now two layers of consequence.

The first layer has existed since the small business rules began. An unfair term in a standard form contract is void (s 23(1) of the ACL), and the contract continues to bind the parties if it is capable of operating without the term (s 23(2) of the ACL). So the rest of the contract usually survives with the offending clause removed. Courts can also declare a term unfair (s 250 of the ACL) and make orders to redress loss or damage caused by the term (s 243A of the ACL).

The second layer started on 9 November 2023. Making a standard form consumer or small business contract that contains an unfair term you proposed is a contravention (s 23(2A) of the ACL), and so is applying or relying on an unfair term (s 23(2C) of the ACL). Each unfair term is a separate contravention (s 23(2B) of the ACL). The maximum civil penalty for a company is the greater of $100 million, three times the value of any benefit obtained, or 30 per cent of adjusted turnover; for an individual it is $2.5 million (s 224 of the ACL). Courts can also grant injunctions and order corrective notices and compliance programs.

This is a significant change. Before 2023 the worst realistic outcome was that a term was struck out and the business had to redraft it. Now the same term can expose the business to penalties and regulator attention.

Where the regime has bitten

The most prominent early small business case shows the pattern. In ACCC v JJ Richards & Sons Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 1224, the waste management company had entered into or renewed around 26,000 standard form contracts since the small business rules commenced. The Federal Court declared eight terms unfair and void, including automatic renewal, unilateral price variation, an indemnity, an exclusivity clause and a one-sided termination right. JJ Richards was restrained from relying on those terms, ordered to publish a corrective notice, and required to run an ACL compliance program.

Regulators have also used outcomes short of court proceedings. In 2019 Uber Eats committed to amending its contracts with restaurants after an ACCC investigation found the terms made restaurants responsible for delivery failures outside their control and gave Uber Eats a broad right to refund customers. In 2024 the ACCC accepted a court-enforceable undertaking from platform provider Mable Technologies, which admitted that its standard terms breached the unfair contract terms provisions, in what was reported as the first enforcement action under the expanded regime.

The pattern across these matters is consistent: businesses that impose template terms on smaller counterparties, particularly platforms, franchisors and suppliers, are the primary targets.

Common traps for businesses

The most common mistakes fall into a few recurring patterns:

  • Assuming negotiation protects you: A contract can still be a standard form contract even where the customer negotiated minor changes or picked from a menu of options.
  • Assuming the regime only protects consumers: Small business contracts have been covered since November 2016, and the definition was widened in 2023.
  • Ignoring renewals and variations: A term varied or added after 9 November 2023 is caught, even in an older contract.
  • Underestimating the size test: Because only one party needs to be a small business, many mid-sized businesses that deal with much smaller counterparties are on the wrong side of the rules.
  • Assuming the price protects you: The upfront price is excluded from challenge, but price variation clauses are not.
  • Relying on opaque drafting: A term buried in dense fine print is less likely to be seen as transparent, and that counts against it.

How a lawyer can help

The practical question for most businesses is whether their own standard form contracts comply. A lawyer can:

  • audit franchise agreements, trading terms, software licences, platform agreements and other template contracts against the regime;
  • advise on whether a particular term is reasonably necessary to protect a legitimate business interest, and how to document that;
  • redraft terms in plain, transparent language, including termination, variation and renewal clauses; and
  • respond to ACCC or ASIC inquiries, or defend or run proceedings about unfair terms.

The ASIC guidance on the 2023 reforms puts the same point simply: businesses should review their standard form contracts now, rather than after a regulator comes knocking.

The real cost of an unreviewed template

The 9 November 2023 changes turned the unfair contract terms rules from a contract law problem into a compliance problem with serious money attached. Where a business once risked losing a clause, it now risks penalties of up to $100 million, corrective notices and regulator scrutiny. For a business that trades on template terms, the cheapest moment to act is before a contract is renewed, before a dispute arises and before a regulator writes its first letter. A focused review of standard form contracts is a modest cost measured against that exposure, and it is exactly the kind of work a contract lawyer can complete quickly once they know which contracts the business actually uses.