- The obligation: grant the leave once it accrues
- When the entitlement accrues: the thresholds
- What you can never do
- Service continuity: where refusal arguments fail
- Consequences of getting it wrong
- A compliance checklist for employers
- When a lawyer should be involved
- The timing decision that costs employers most
Long service leave is the paid leave that rewards an employee for staying with the same employer for years, and it is the entitlement employers most often assume they can manage informally. Once the statutory threshold is met, the entitlement is not discretionary: an employer who refuses long service leave is acting unlawfully unless the refusal fits within narrow timing rules, and there are some things that are never lawful, such as paying the leave out or contracting out of the obligation.
This article sets out who owes long service leave and when it accrues, the test for refusing or deferring a request in the two largest states, the practices that are always off limits, what happens when an employer gets it wrong, and a checklist you can act on this week.
The obligation: grant the leave once it accrues
Long service leave is one of the ten minimum standards that make up the National Employment Standards under s 61(2)(g) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). But the Fair Work Act does not itself spell out how much leave an employee gets or when. Division 9 of the Act provides that an employee is entitled to long service leave in accordance with applicable award-derived terms, and the Act expressly does not displace state and territory long service leave laws, except in limited cases (s 113). Modern awards, for their part, must not include terms dealing with long service leave at all (s 155).
The practical result is that for most employees the operative rules come from the long service leave Act of the state or territory where they work, and the Fair Work Ombudsman directs employers to their local long service leave agency to find the detail. This article focuses on New South Wales and Victoria, where the two largest groups of employees work, and notes where the position differs elsewhere.
The obligation applies to any employee who builds up the required period of continuous service with one employer. In New South Wales the Long Service Leave Act 1955 (NSW) defines service as continuous service "whether on a permanent, casual, part-time or any other basis", so long-serving casuals count. Victoria's Long Service Leave Act 2018 (Vic) has its own continuity rules that can preserve an employee's service across certain absences, discussed below.
When the entitlement accrues: the thresholds
The qualifying period is the first thing to check, because it determines whether an employee has any entitlement at all:
- New South Wales: an employee who completes 10 years' service is entitled to 2 months' long service leave, with a further month for each 5 years completed after that (a "month" is 4 and one-third weeks). An employee whose service ends after at least 5 years is entitled to a proportionate amount on the basis of 2 months per 10 years if the termination is by the employer for any reason other than serious and wilful misconduct, or by the worker on account of illness, incapacity or domestic or other pressing necessity, or by death (s 4 of the NSW Act).
- Victoria: an employee is entitled, at any time after completing 7 years of continuous employment, to an amount equal to 1/60th of the total period of continuous employment, less any long service leave already taken (s 6 of the Victorian Act).
- Other states and territories: the qualifying period varies, and in most jurisdictions it is around ten years of continuous service. The accrual rate, the treatment of casuals, and the circumstances in which a pro-rata payment is made on earlier termination all differ, so the local Act should be checked before any decision is made about a specific employee.
Two features of these thresholds matter for employers. First, the entitlement is tied to service with the one employer, so a change of business ownership can either preserve or extinguish service depending on the rules. Second, the entitlement accrues as a matter of law, not by agreement: an employer cannot set its own lower threshold in an employment contract.
The refusal test: it is about when, not whether
Once the entitlement has accrued, the statute is framed around when the leave must be given, not whether the employee gets it at all. Refusal in the true sense is therefore rare. What an employer can legitimately do is defer the leave, or direct when it is taken, within limits set by the Act.
In New South Wales, s 4(3) of the Long Service Leave Act requires the employer to give, and the worker to take, the leave "as soon as is practicable having regard to the needs of the employer's establishment", or from an agreed date if the parties agree to postpone it. The employer must also give at least one month's notice of the date from which it proposes the leave be taken, although the worker can agree to a shorter notice period (s 4(10) and s 4(10A)). If the employer cannot make the requested dates work, the statutory machinery therefore supports agreeing a later date, not refusing the leave outright.
In Victoria, s 18 of the Long Service Leave Act 2018 gives the employee the right to request leave of not less than one day, and requires the employer to grant the request "as soon as practicable" unless the employer has reasonable business grounds for refusing it. The Act also lets the employer take the initiative: under s 19, an employer may direct an employee to take long service leave at a specified time and for a specified period, provided the employee is given at least 12 weeks' written notice.
What counts as a reasonable ground for refusing a request, or as impracticability having regard to the needs of the establishment, is an operational judgment. Genuine peaks in trading, project deadlines, staffing coverage, or a clash with leave already approved for other employees can all justify deferring a request to a later date. What will not justify a refusal is a bare preference, cash-flow convenience, or a belief that the employee "doesn't deserve" the leave. Where a refusal is not grounded in the statutory test, the employee can insist on taking the leave as soon as practicable, and the employer's refusal becomes an underpayment of the entitlement.
Direction, splitting and leave in advance
The Acts give employers some control over the shape of the leave. In New South Wales, leave must be taken in one continuous period unless the parties agree to separate periods of at least one day (s 4(3)(b) and s 4(3AA) of the NSW Act). In both states the parties can agree to split the leave. An employer and employee can also agree to the employee taking long service leave in advance before the entitlement accrues (s 4(3A) of the NSW Act and s 8 of the Victorian Act). Leave in advance is a useful tool for covering a planned absence, but it carries risk: if the employee leaves before the entitlement accrues, the employer can deduct the amount paid for the advanced leave from final pay, and disputes about that deduction are common.
What you can never do
Three practices are prohibited outright, and they are the ones that turn an otherwise defensible timing decision into a breach:
- No payment in lieu while employment continues: In New South Wales, s 4(8) of the Long Service Leave Act provides that payment must not be made in lieu of long service leave, or any part of it, except where the worker's service is terminated and the accrued leave is paid out on termination under s 4(5). In Victoria, s 34 of the Long Service Leave Act 2018 makes it an offence for an employer to give a payment in lieu of long service leave except as permitted by the Act, another Act or a relevant fair work instrument. The Victorian offence carries a penalty of 12 penalty units for an individual and 60 penalty units for a body corporate, and the employee commits an offence by accepting such a payment.
- No contracting out: An employment contract cannot annul, vary or exclude the protections of the Acts. Section 7 of the NSW Act makes any stipulation to the contrary ineffective, and s 23 of the Victorian Act provides that a provision in an employment agreement that annuls, varies or excludes the Act is of no effect. A clause that says long service leave is "included in salary" or that the employee "waives" the entitlement is void.
- No short cuts on records: Long service leave records must be kept properly and for long periods. Under s 8 of the NSW Act a record must be kept for at least 6 years after the worker ceases employment. Under s 37 of the Victorian Act the record must be kept during the period of continuous employment and for at least 7 years after the employee stops working, with penalties of 12 penalty units for an individual and 60 for a body corporate.
Service continuity: where refusal arguments fail
Employers sometimes argue that a break in service, a stand-down, or a transfer between related entities means the entitlement never accrued. The Acts close most of those doors, and the arguments rarely succeed.
In New South Wales, service is deemed continuous despite interruptions caused by illness or injury, industrial disputes, slackness of trade, absence by leave of the employer, or re-employment within two months of a break (s 4(11)(a) of the NSW Act). A transmission of the business does not break continuity, and service with the previous owner counts as service with the new owner (s 4(11)(c)). Related corporations are treated as a single employer for continuity purposes (s 4(13)).
In Victoria, continuous employment is preserved across annual leave, long service leave, parental leave, leave on account of illness or injury, and other forms of leave under the employment agreement (s 12 of the Victorian Act). Unpaid leave beyond the first 52 weeks does not count toward the length of continuous employment unless the employment agreement provides otherwise, the parties agreed in writing in advance, or the leave is taken on account of illness or injury (s 14).
The COVID-19 pandemic produced a specific example of continuity being protected by legislation. In New South Wales, s 15C of the Long Service Leave Act provides that if a worker was stood down without pay as a direct or indirect result of the pandemic during the prescribed period, which ran from 11 March 2020 to 30 September 2021 (extendable by regulation to 31 March 2022), the worker's service is taken to be continuous and the worker kept accruing long service leave while stood down. The provision extends to long service leave entitlements under other Acts, including the building and construction portable schemes. The lesson for employers is that continuity rules can operate in surprising ways, and a stand-down or restructure is exactly the moment to check how service is being counted.
Consequences of getting it wrong
An unlawful refusal to grant long service leave is, in substance, an underpayment of an accrued entitlement, and the consequences escalate quickly:
- Recovery of the amount: Unpaid long service leave is recoverable as a debt. In New South Wales the Act provides for recovery of amounts payable under s 4 in the same manner as amounts under s 12 of the Act, and in Victoria disputes over entitlements are determined in the Industrial Division of the Magistrates' Court. Interest and costs can be added.
- Penalties: The Victorian Act attaches penalties to the conduct most likely to tempt an employer, including the payment-in-lieu offence and the record-keeping offences (12 penalty units for an individual and 60 for a body corporate in each case). Directors and other people involved in the management of a corporation can face executive liability for offences against s 4 of the NSW Act.
- Regulator action: The Fair Work Ombudsman and state workplace regulators investigate complaints about unpaid long service leave and can recover amounts on behalf of employees.
- General protections exposure: Dismissing, or otherwise prejudicing, an employee because they sought to take long service leave can also expose the business to an adverse action claim under Part 3-1 of the Fair Work Act. An entitlement to the benefit of a workplace law is a "workplace right" for these purposes (s 341 of the Act), and long service leave legislation is a workplace law. The Fair Work Commission can conciliate these claims and, if they are not resolved, they proceed to court with significant penalties and compensation available.
A compliance checklist for employers
The following steps keep a business on the right side of the long service leave rules:
- Identify the governing Act: confirm which state or territory long service leave law applies to each employee, and check whether a portable long service leave scheme applies to the industry.
- Track continuous service accurately: include casual and part-time service, and record absences that preserve continuity, such as illness, parental leave and approved leave.
- Respond to requests in writing: when an employee requests long service leave, grant it as soon as practicable. If you need to defer it, record the operational ground and agree a firm later date.
- Use the statutory tools for timing: propose dates with proper notice (at least one month in NSW, less by agreement), and use the Victorian direction power with its 12 weeks' notice where the business genuinely needs to schedule the leave.
- Never pay out accrued leave while employment continues: the only lawful payout is on termination, and then only if the Act allows it.
- Never ask an employee to waive long service leave: any contract clause that excludes or reduces the entitlement is void.
- Keep records for the full statutory period: at least 6 years after employment ends in NSW, and 7 years in Victoria.
- Get advice before restructuring or standing down staff: business sales, related-entity transfers and stand-downs all raise continuity questions that determine whether the entitlement exists at all.
When a lawyer should be involved
The points at which long service leave becomes a legal problem, rather than a payroll matter, are identifiable in advance. A lawyer should be involved when an employer wants to refuse or defer a specific request and the grounds are not clear-cut, when a long-serving employee leaves or is dismissed (pro-rata calculations are a frequent source of dispute), when a business is sold or restructured, and when a regulator or court claim has been made. A practitioner can identify the governing Act, calculate the entitlement correctly including continuity issues, advise on whether a proposed refusal meets the statutory test, and respond to a claim before it becomes a penalty. For a business facing its first underpayment claim over long service leave, the cost of that advice is small against the penalties and general protections exposure that follow a loss.
The timing decision that costs employers most
The refusal that causes the most damage is not the outright "no" to a leave request, because most employers know that sounds wrong. It is the informal settlement that looks reasonable at the time: paying out the leave so the employee keeps working, or signing off a contract clause that trades the entitlement away. Both are prohibited outright, and both convert a straightforward entitlement into a penalty exposure and a regulator's file. The test to remember is that a lawful refusal is only ever a justified deferral, grounded in the needs of the establishment or reasonable business grounds, with a firm date attached. If a request has come in and the answer feels like "no", the practical first step is to pull the service records for the employee, confirm which Act applies and what has accrued, and put a date on when the leave can be taken.